The Appointment Nobody Keeps

More than one in four patients stopped coming to follow-up before twelve months in a Japanese single-centre cohort — and living alone, not distance, was the variable that stuck. A US research cohort kept 88 percent of its adolescents for a decade.

bariatric surgerylong-term outcomesaccess to careresearch

The clinic is at Ohama Daiichi Hospital in Naha, on Okinawa. Between April 2015 and August 2022 its surgeons performed primary metabolic and bariatric operations on 339 consecutive patients, revisional cases excluded, and the team went back through the records to ask a narrow question: how many of them were still showing up a year later. The answer, published in Obesity Surgery on 6 November, is that 85.8 percent attended at six months and 73.2 percent at twelve — 91 patients, or 26.8 percent of the cohort, gone before the first anniversary.

This is a retrospective single-centre review, the weakest kind of evidence in the hierarchy, and the authors label their own findings exploratory. But it is also one of the few attempts to count attrition in an Asian bariatric population, where the authors note such data are scarce, and the arithmetic is the same arithmetic clinics everywhere live with. More than a quarter of a surgical cohort discontinued follow-up before what the paper calls the minimum interval required for guideline-concordant care.

The household, not the highway

What predicted the disappearance is the interesting part. Distance from the hospital did not. Travel time did not. Neither did marital status, psychiatric care, sex, age, or baseline BMI. Living alone did: 40.4 percent of patients living by themselves were lost to follow-up, against 24.1 percent of those living with others, and the adjusted odds ratio held at 2.11 (95 percent CI 1.08 to 4.12) after multiple imputation for missing data. The second independent association was calendar time — each later operative year carried 33 percent higher odds of attrition (1.11 to 1.59).

The authors make their own case modestly, and it is worth repeating in their terms rather than a press release’s. The model’s discrimination was poor, with an AUC of 0.550, which means that although living alone moves risk at the level of a group, it cannot pick out an individual patient who will stop coming. “Living alone is offered as one element of a multidimensional assessment, not a screening test,” they write. Their practical point is smaller and more useful than a screening tool: household composition is already recorded in the preoperative psychosocial evaluation, so acting on it requires no new instrument and no new appointment. It requires someone to notice.

That finding also quietly dismantles a common assumption. If travel were the barrier, telehealth and outreach to rural patients would be the answer. In this cohort the patients who lived far away came back at the same rate as the patients who lived nearby. The risk sat inside the household.

What a research budget buys

The contrast that gives the Okinawan numbers their scale comes from the other end of the age range, and from a completely different kind of operation: a study. Teen-LABS, the adolescent arm of the Longitudinal Assessment of Bariatric Surgery consortium that NIDDK funded, enrolled 242 teenagers between 2007 and 2012 and followed them for a decade, closing in 2022. In a report published in Surgery for Obesity and Related Diseases this spring, in-person visit attendance averaged 86 percent across the whole follow-up, and 88 percent of participants were still engaged at ten years.

That is a decade of retention at a rate the Okinawan clinic could not reach in twelve months. The Teen-LABS authors attribute it to the retention strategies their staff ran — the tracing, the scheduling, the deliberate work of keeping adolescents attached to a cohort as they became adults — and they are candid that even inside that machinery some participants missed visits more often. Sleep apnea, public insurance, psychiatric medication use, and caregiver race and employment status all marked higher rates of missed appointments.

Then comes the sentence that complicates the whole subject. Body mass index trajectory, comorbidity status, independence and lifestyle factors over time did not differ significantly by attendance group. In a cohort followed with a protocol close to the schedule the LABS study itself used for adults — before surgery, at six months, at one year, then annually through 2015, as the NIDDK study page describes — the patients who missed visits did not visibly do worse. The same research archive holds the raw material of that schedule; the LABS study archive sets out the design.

Fifty-six patients and a doubling

Against that null sits a paper from the Mayo Clinic published in Surgical Endoscopy in October. It followed 56 adults for a mean of 29 months after endoscopic sleeve gastroplasty, an endoscopic rather than surgical procedure, and split them by how much clinician contact they had: five or more visits after the procedure, or fewer. The close-follow-up group lost 13.7 percent of body weight at last follow-up; the limited group lost 6.7 percent (p = 0.01). A larger share of the closely followed patients crossed the 10, 15 and 20 percent thresholds. Exercise participation, reported by 69.7 percent, showed a numerically larger loss that was not statistically significant.

Twice the weight loss is a striking gap for a difference in appointment count, and the study cannot explain it. Fifty-six patients at one tertiary centre, retrospectively sorted, with a definition of “close” drawn at five visits — the sort of design that invites a reader to supply the causal story the data cannot. The authors’ own interpretation is that structured engagement by physicians and advanced practice clinicians matters, not only contact with dietitians.

The direction nobody has settled

Read together, the three papers point in opposite directions on the question that actually matters: does attending follow-up produce better outcomes, or do patients with better outcomes simply attend? Teen-LABS, with its high retention and its null result across attendance groups, leans toward attendance as a marker. Mayo leans toward it as a lever. Neither randomises retention support, so neither closes the question, and the plausible third explanation — that patients who regain weight or feel ashamed stop coming, while those who feel well see no reason to return — sits unmeasured in both.

What is not in doubt is that the visits being missed are the visits that catch something. NIDDK’s patient page on side effects states plainly that follow-up interventions, surgery and hospitalisations are relatively common within five years of weight-loss surgery, affecting about one-third of patients, and that follow-up procedures are needed more often after gastric bypass than after sleeve gastrectomy. Strictures, hernias, anemia and bone loss are found at appointments. The psychiatric finding cuts the same way in both directions: the Japanese study found documented psychiatric care carried no excess attrition risk, while Teen-LABS found psychiatric medication use predicted missed visits — two cohorts, two measurements, no shared definition. The mental-health literature has run into the same problem of who returns to be counted.

The Okinawan authors put their result in the form of a clinic’s arithmetic rather than a patient’s fate: roughly one additional patient lost for every six living alone. That is a number a scheduler could work with. It is not a diagnosis, and nothing in any of these papers argues for or against surgery in an individual case — only for noticing that the twelve-month visit, which the field treats as a formality, is the step where a quarter of a cohort quietly leaves.

Sources

  1. Inamine S, Uesato Y. Living Alone is Associated with Loss to Follow-up after Metabolic and Bariatric Surgery. Obesity Surgery, published online 6 November 2026.
  2. Rode JB, Ogle SB, Khoury JC, et al. Long-term study retention of adolescents undergoing metabolic and bariatric surgery: lessons learned from the Teen-Longitudinal Assessment of Bariatric Surgery cohort. Surgery for Obesity and Related Diseases 2026;22(5):517-524.
  3. Ghusn W, Matar A, Al Annan K, et al. Long-term outcomes after endoscopic sleeve gastroplasty: impact of clinician follow-up and lifestyle engagement. Surgical Endoscopy 2026;40(10):8622-8629.
  4. NIDDK. Weight-loss Surgery Side Effects (patient information page).
  5. NIDDK. Long-term Study of Bariatric Surgery for Obesity: LABS.
From the blog

New research notes